Re: Help...Verify UML Design

Re: Help...Verify UML Design

From: Pierre-Yves Schobbens <>
Date: Thu, 29 Jun 2006 11:36:17 +0200
Message-Id: <>
Le 28-juin-06 à 14:01, Islam Essam a écrit :

> The problem with (a) is that Enterprises will never
> let their designs go out of their organizations, and
> it is logic.

There is a exception: when a public body calls for a development by  
they usually require a deposit of the sources, and even sometimes in  
a public repository.
If we could convince them to require to make the models public as  
well, we would rapidly have a huge base of models.

> The problem with (b) is that Technical Papers just put
> a very small portion of the design to illustrate a
> specific point. You will never find a complete UML
> design in such papers.

Similarly, specialised conferences could require all technical papers  
to deposit their full models in the repository. Indeed, science must  
be repeatable and other disciplines already have such requirements.

> The problem with (c) is that Students make their
> projects by the book (very academic), so you cannot
> test real life problems that will happen in real large
> projects,

Agreed, but it is nevertheless interesting as typical cases of  
beginners' mistakes,
and about the variety of strange things that people do when faced to  
the same problem.
Received on Thu 29 Jun 2006 - 10:37:26 BST